This data-driven investigation reveals how Hungary, Romania and Poland have used — and misused — millions of euros of EU funds intended to help countries recover from the COVID-19 pandemic.
Journalists and tech activists based in the three countries known for mismanaging EU subsidies join forces to scrutinise spending from NextGenerationEU, the bloc’s €750-billion instrument to make post-pandemic Europe greener, more digital and more resilient.
The project is a collaboration between Romanian transparency watchdog Funky Citizens, its data journalism platform Buletin de București, independent Hungarian news portal 444.hu, Hungarian anti-corruption group K-Monitor and Polish civic tech group ePaństwo.
In Romania, the team examines spending of €1.5 million of EU recovery funds by the Hospital and Medical Service Administration in Bucharest after an emergency presidential decree removed financial limits on direct purchases.
With normal procurement processes suspended, the administration made most of its purchases of medical supplies behind closed doors, the investigation finds. Companies contracted to provide hospitals with ventilators and COVID-19 PCR tests, for example, often lacked experience or were politically connected.
The team also probed more than €4.8 million in spending by the Balș Institute in Bucharest, a hospital on the frontline of the fight against coronavirus.
One company that supplied medical equipment to the institute, Dutchmed, received almost half a million euros in contracts signed behind closed doors and without negotiation, the team reveals. Several years ago, Dutchmed’s owner was accused of bribing health ministry employees to get lucrative contracts.
Another company that supplied monitoring stations to the institute was found to have provided another hospital in Bucharest with overpriced personal protective equipment for doctors. And the list goes on, with companies owned by former ministry advisers scooping up contracts.
One story exposes dubious purchases of luxury pyjamas and robes for doctors from a fashion brand, a company that went from putting together road trips for public authorities to publicity for hospitals and the purchase of face masks above market price.
In Hungary, the team’s findings belie claims by populist Prime Minister Viktor Orbán that the EU has not made funds available to help with the pandemic while China and Turkey have swooped to the rescue.
In fact, the pandemic has made previously unspent subsidies from the EU’s 2014-2020 budget exempt from normal tendering processes, allowing the government to reallocate funds.
Budapest redeployed more than €320 million to help small and medium-sized businesses. Meanwhile, Brussels greenlighted millions more for reallocation to at least three domestic support programmes — approval that came just days after Orbán told Hungarians that only the Turks and Chinese were offering help.
In Poland, the team investigates the purchase of computer equipment allowing employees of ministries and other public institutions to work from home following temporary legislation that overrode public procurement regulations.
Among other things, the investigation reveals that the Ministry of Digital Affairs signed a €10 million contract for computers on the day before the temporary legislation expired. Some of that spending came from EU funds.
Cover image by Ion Mateș
- Banii europeni în pandemie. Ep.1. Bani cheltuiți fără transparență de Administrația Spitalelor București (European funds during the pandemic. Ep.1. Money spend without transparency by the Bucharest Hospital Administration) ( Buletin de București, Romania, 23 March 2021 )
- Institutul Balș | Banii europeni pentru combaterea pandemiei, la o firmă acuzată de dare de mită (Balș Institute | European funds aimed at fighting the pandemic go to a company accused of bribery) ( Buletin de București, Romania, 29 March 2021 )
- Spitalele din Capitală, în pandemie: Fonduri europene de 95 milioane de lei, unele ajunse la firme controversate (Hospitals in the Capital, during the pandemic | European funds in excess of 19 million, some of which ended with controversial companies) ( Buletin de București, Romania, 28 April 2021 )
- Budapest lerohasztása: a fővárosnak járó EU-s támogatások 80 százalékát a kormány akarja elosztani, főleg az atlétikai stadion környékére (Demolition of Budapest: 80 percent of EU subsidies for the capital to be distributed by the government, mainly around the athletics stadium) ( 444.hu, Hungary, 9 February 2021 )
- Jött EU-s pénz a covid ellen, csak a kormány nem beszél róla (EU money arrived to help the fight against covid, but the government is not talking about it) ( 444.hu, Hungary, 18 February 2021 )
- Átszervezte Orbán az EU-s stábot a nagy brüsszeli pénzeső előtt (Orbán reorganized the EU headquarters ahead of big Brussels money) ( 444.hu, Hungary, 22 March 2021 )